PART SEVEN: HISTORY AND NEIGHBORS

MYTH CHECK

Myth: "The Council of Nicea picked the books of the Bible"

2 MIN READ

ON THIS PAGE8 SECTIONS
  1. 1What you'll notice
  2. 2What it's called
  3. 3What's actually happening
  4. 4Why it matters
  5. 5Where it came from
  6. 6What you do
  7. 7Go deeper
  8. 8Notes

THE SHORT ANSWER

Nicea (325) dealt with Arius and the date of Pascha; none of its twenty canons lists the books of the Bible.

What you'll notice

You'll hear it online: in 325 a roomful of bishops voted on which books made the Bible.

What it's called

The canon of Scripture is the list of books the Church reads as Scripture. The same word names a church rule, so Nicea's twenty "canons" are rules, not book lists.

What's actually happening

Nicea met to answer Arius, who taught that the Son was a creature. It gave the Church the core of the Creed, settled that all Christians should keep Pascha together, and issued twenty canons on church order.1 Not one of them lists books.

Why it matters

The Bible is the Church's book, read in the Liturgy long before anyone wrote a table of contents. The Church didn't create the canon so much as recognize what it had been reading all along. Scripture and Tradition has the rest.

Where it came from

It took centuries of churches reading certain books in worship and recognizing them as apostolic. The first surviving list of exactly our twenty-seven New Testament books comes from Saint Athanasius in his Festal Letter of 367, forty-two years after Nicea.2 Regional councils such as Carthage issued lists, which the Council in Trullo (692) received into the Church's law.3

The myth comes from a good story. A Byzantine collection, the Synodicon Vetus, probably from the late ninth century, says the fathers laid the disputed books by the altar and prayed, and the true ones ended up on top.4 Saint Jerome even mentions a report that Nicea counted Judith among the Scriptures.5 It made better copy than four centuries of reading.

What you do

If you're Orthodox: when it comes up, name Athanasius and 367.

If you're visiting: listen to the readings; you're hearing the canon used the way it was formed.

Notes

  1. Nicea I, canons 1–20 (NPNF2 14). ↩

  2. Athanasius, Festal Letter 39 (NPNF2 4). ↩

  3. Council in Trullo, canon 2 (NPNF2 14). ↩

  4. Wikipedia, "Synodicon Vetus." ↩

  5. Jerome, Preface to Judith. ↩

Contact and Corrections: send a note about this page →