Salvation and the Christian life
Are you saved? When did you get saved?
If you grew up with a date written in the front of your Bible, the Orthodox answer can sound like a dodge. It isn't one. You'll often hear it in three tenses: I was saved (Christ died and rose, and I was baptized into him), I am being saved ("work out your own salvation with fear and trembling; for it is God who works in you," Philippians 2:12–13), and I hope to be saved on the last day ("we were saved in this hope," Romans 8:24).
Southern Baptists confess that God "regenerates, justifies, sanctifies, and glorifies sinners," and that "all true believers endure to the end" (Baptist Faith and Message, art. V). The Orthodox share your confidence that salvation is Christ's gift and never your achievement. Where they part ways is on treating one past moment as a guarantee no matter what follows. Their assurance rests on Christ, renewed in repentance and at the chalice, and it's meant to give you peace, not a scorecard. Salvation as Healing, Field Note "Can I be sure of God's mercy?", goes further.
Sources: Philippians 2:12–13; Romans 8:24 (NKJV). Baptist Faith and Message (2000), art. V.
Where's the personal relationship with Jesus in all this?
The phrase isn't in the Orthodox vocabulary, but what you mean by it is everywhere once you know where to look. Jesus' own word is "abide": "He who eats My flesh and drinks My blood abides in Me, and I in him" (John 6:56). He defines eternal life as knowing him: "that they may know You, the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom You have sent" (John 17:3).
At the chalice the priest says your name, not "the congregation," and gives you Christ's Body and Blood on a spoon. That's about as personal as it gets. At home, Orthodox Christians keep morning and evening prayers in front of an icon of Christ, and many pray the Jesus Prayer all day: "Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, a sinner."
What might feel missing is the spontaneous, conversational style. The Orthodox would say the relationship is real precisely because it doesn't depend on how you feel this week. Your love for Jesus is welcome here. Prayer at Home and Communion show what it looks like day to day.
Sources: John 6:56; John 17:3 (NKJV). Hapgood, Service Book, Divine Liturgy, p. 119 (the communicant named at the chalice).
What does 'have mercy on me' mean in the Jesus Prayer?
The prayer is "Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, a sinner." If "mercy" sounds to you like being let off a punishment, the Orthodox mean more than that. You're asking Christ to forgive you, to heal you and to bring you back into communion with him. It's a prayer of repentance, and just as much a prayer of trust in his love.
Luke gives three pictures of it. The tax collector "would not so much as raise his eyes to heaven, but beat his breast, saying, 'God, be merciful to me a sinner!'" and Jesus says he went down to his house justified (Luke 18:13–14). A blind man cries out, "Jesus, Son of David, have mercy on me!" and what he wants is his sight (Luke 18:38–42). Ten lepers call, "Jesus, Master, have mercy on us!" and are cleansed as they go (Luke 17:13–14). Each is asking for something only Christ can give: forgiveness, sight, cleansing. So you can hear the prayer this way: Lord, forgive me, heal what's wounded in me, and help me live in you. That isn't a replacement translation, only a way to open up what the words already ask.
It's not a way of talking God into being kind. "God demonstrates His own love toward us, in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us" (Romans 5:8). He isn't reluctant to love you. Praying for mercy opens you to the mercy he already offers. And you don't need to produce a particular feeling when you pray. Start simply and attentively, with repentance and trust. Prayer at Home shows how Orthodox Christians use the prayer through the day.
Sources: Luke 17:13–14; Luke 18:13–14, 38–42; Romans 5:8 (NKJV).
Was Jesus really tempted if he couldn't sin?
Yes, truly. Hebrews says he was "in all points tempted as we are, yet without sin" (Hebrews 4:15). The temptations in the wilderness were real attacks from the outside, and Christ really felt hunger, weariness, and the weight of the Cross.
Where the question has a point is this: there was nothing in Christ that sin could grab onto. We're tempted from within, because our passions pull us toward sin. Christ had a full human nature, but no fallen passions and no inner inclination to sin, so the temptation came only from outside. In that sense, Satan did "try" to tempt him and failed completely.
The Fathers say he defeated the devil precisely as a man, healing our humanity from the inside by saying no where Adam said yes. Saint John of Damascus, in the eighth century, wrote that Christ "assumed all the natural and innocent passions of man," such as hunger, thirst, weariness and the shrinking from death, but not sin. Of the wilderness he wrote: "The wicked one, then, made his assault from without, not by thoughts prompted inwardly, just as it was with Adam."
Sources: Hebrews 4:15 (NKJV). Saint John of Damascus, Exposition of the Orthodox Faith III.20, "Concerning the natural and innocent passions" (NPNF2 9).
Do you believe in justification by faith alone?
Your confessions say it carefully. Augsburg: we're justified "freely for Christ's sake, through faith" (art. IV). Westminster: God pardons and accepts the sinner "not by infusing righteousness into them" but by imputing Christ's obedience and satisfaction, and the faith that receives it is "the alone instrument of justification" (11.1–2). Both also insist that true faith bears fruit.
The Orthodox agree that forgiveness and righteousness are pure gift; nobody earns them. They don't use the "alone" formulas, because they don't separate being declared righteous from being made righteous. James says "a man is justified by works, and not by faith only" (James 2:24); Paul speaks of "faith working through love" (Galatians 5:6). The Orthodox read both apostles as describing one healing, in which God's grace comes first and our response is real. The clearest Orthodox statement is the Confession of Dositheus (Jerusalem, 1672), which rejects justification "through faith alone" in favor of faith working through love. It's a local synod answering the Reformation, not an ecumenical council.
So the honest answer is no, though not in the sense you might fear. Salvation as Healing explains the picture behind it.
Sources: Augsburg Confession, arts. IV, VI. Westminster Confession 11.1–2. James 2:24; Galatians 5:6 (NKJV). Confession of Dositheus (1672), Decree 13.
Isn't synergy just semi-Pelagianism with incense?
The worry is fair. Westminster teaches that in effectual calling a person is "altogether passive" until the Spirit renews him (10.2), and the Reformed tradition hears "cooperation" as a claim that we start the work.
The Orthodox don't. Grace comes first, before anyone moves toward God; the Church condemned Pelagius's followers at Ephesus in 431, and it agrees with you that no one is saved by his own steam. What the Orthodox deny is that grace overrides the will. Their proof text is the same one you'd use, read whole: "work out your own salvation with fear and trembling; for it is God who works in you both to will and to do" (Philippians 2:12–13). God works; you work; his work makes yours possible.
"Semi-Pelagian" is a Western label from a Western quarrel (Augustine, Cassian, and later Rome and the Reformers). The East never framed the question that way, which is why the label fits badly. Salvation as Healing, "What's actually happening," sets out synergy in the Guide's terms.
Sources: Westminster Confession 10.2. Philippians 2:12–13 (NKJV). Council of Ephesus (431), canons 1 and 4 (NPNF2 14). Formula of Concord, Epitome II.10 ("Semi-Pelagians").
Do you believe in original sin? Total depravity?
Westminster teaches that Adam's guilt is "imputed" to all his descendants and that we're "utterly indisposed, disabled, and made opposite to all good" (6.3–6.4). The Orthodox take the fall just as seriously and describe it differently.
From Adam we inherit a wounded world and nature, subject to corruption and death, and a will bent away from God. We don't inherit personal guilt for an act we didn't commit. The Orthodox call this ancestral sin. Romans 5:12 is the key text, and its last phrase has been read different ways since the Fathers. The image of God in us is damaged, not erased; that's why a sinner can still recognize the good and grieve over failing it. We still need grace for every good thing, and we commit plenty of sins of our own.
That difference shows up at the font. An infant is baptized to receive Christ's life, not to cancel inherited guilt. Catholics, interestingly, also say original sin doesn't have "the character of a personal fault" in Adam's descendants (CCC 405). Salvation as Healing, "What's actually happening," has the Guide's account.
Sources: Westminster Confession 6.3–6.4. Romans 5:12 (NKJV). Catechism of the Catholic Church 405.
Can a true Christian lose their salvation?
Westminster says those whom God has effectually called "can neither totally nor finally fall away from the state of grace" (17.1). The Baptist Faith and Message: "All true believers endure to the end" (art. V). Lutherans, notably, went the other way; the Augsburg Confession condemns those "who deny that those once justified can lose the Holy Ghost" (art. XII).
The Orthodox stand nearer Augsburg here. Nobody can snatch you out of Christ's hand (John 10:28), but you can walk away from it. Paul disciplined himself "lest, when I have preached to others, I myself should become disqualified" (1 Corinthians 9:27), and Hebrews warns about those who fall away after tasting the heavenly gift (Hebrews 6:4–6).
That isn't meant to keep you anxious. The cure for falling is getting up, and the Church gives you confession for exactly that. A desert father told a monk who kept falling to get up again, "until your death." Salvation as Healing, Field Note "Can I be sure of God's mercy?", is the Guide's answer.
Sources: Westminster Confession 17.1. Baptist Faith and Message (2000), art. V. Augsburg Confession, art. XII. John 10:28; 1 Corinthians 9:27; Hebrews 6:4–6 (NKJV). Sayings of the Desert Fathers, Sisoes 14, as told on What Happens After Death?
Worship, prayer and the sacraments
Isn't reading prayers off a page just vain repetition?
Here's the verse: "And when you pray, do not use vain repetitions as the heathen do. For they think that they will be heard for their many words" (Matthew 6:7). The Orthodox read it as a warning against prayer used like a slot machine, words stacked up to wear God down. It can't be a ban on repeating, because two verses later Jesus hands his disciples a set prayer (Matthew 6:9–13). In Gethsemane he "prayed the third time, saying the same words" (Matthew 26:44). The living creatures in Revelation "do not rest day or night, saying: 'Holy, holy, holy'" (Revelation 4:8).
You probably sing the same hymns every year and say the Lord's Prayer by heart, and your worship team may sing a chorus eight times. The Orthodox do the same thing, on purpose. Inherited words take away the pressure to be original on a Sunday morning; the work is meaning them. Forty "Lord, have mercy"s are the tax collector's prayer (Luke 18:13), kept up. Orthodox and Protestant, "Liturgy," has the wider picture.
Sources: Matthew 6:7, 6:9–13, 26:44; Revelation 4:8; Luke 18:13 (NKJV).
Why do I need a priest to forgive my sins? I confess straight to God.
The scribes in Mark 2 asked the same thing: "Who can forgive sins but God alone?" (Mark 2:7). The Orthodox agree with the scribes on that point. The surprise is how Matthew ends the story: the crowds "glorified God, who had given such power to men" (Matthew 9:8). After the Resurrection Jesus passes it on: "If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them" (John 20:23).
Orthodox Christians do confess straight to God, every night, in their own prayers. The sacrament adds a witness. In the Russian rite the priest tells the penitent that Christ is standing there invisibly and receiving the confession, "and I am but a witness." Many evangelical churches teach confession to God alone (1 John 1:9); Lutherans, for the record, kept private absolution on purpose (Augsburg Confession, art. XI). Saying it out loud to a person turns private regret into actual repentance, and you hear "forgiven" in a human voice. Confession walks through the rite.
Sources: Mark 2:7; Matthew 9:8; John 20:23; 1 John 1:9 (NKJV). Hapgood, Service Book (1906), Office of Confession, p. 289. Augsburg Confession, art. XI.
Why baptize a baby who can't believe yet?
Southern Baptists confess that "Christian baptism is the immersion of a believer in water" in the Trinity's name, and that it pictures a faith already present (Baptist Faith and Message, art. VII). The Orthodox see baptism the other way round: God acts first, and faith grows inside what he's done. That's why Peter tells the crowd at Pentecost that "the promise is to you and to your children" (Acts 2:39), and why Lydia and the Philippian jailer were baptized with their households (Acts 16:15, 33). Israel brought its sons into the covenant at eight days old.
A baby can't believe yet. A baby can't consent to being fed either, and nobody waits. In baptism the child is joined to Christ's death and resurrection; the godparent answers for the child and says the Creed aloud, and the godparent and family take on the work of raising that faith. Most Christians through history have baptized infants, Lutherans (Augsburg, art. IX) and Presbyterians (Westminster 28.4) included. The Field Note "why baptize a baby?" on Baptism and Chrismation has more.
Sources: Acts 2:39; Acts 16:15, 33; Genesis 17:12 (NKJV). Baptist Faith and Message (2000), art. VII. Augsburg Confession, art. IX. Westminster Confession 28.4. Hapgood, Service Book, Office of Holy Baptism, pp. 275–276.
I was baptized by immersion as a believer. Will you make me do it again?
Probably not, but it isn't your call or the parish priest's. Your bishop decides, and the priest applies his practice.
If you were baptized with water in the name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit, many bishops in America (the OCA, the Greek and Antiochian archdioceses among them) receive you by chrismation, usually after a first confession. Some bishops and some monasteries baptize converts as a rule; the bishops of the Russian Church Abroad ruled in 1971 that converts be baptized, allowing chrismation only where strictly necessary and with a bishop's permission. Both sides read the same ancient canons. Some treat baptism as the strict reading and chrismation as an easing of it. Others read the canons themselves as prescribing chrismation for some cases, so that chrismating them is the canon kept exactly. Either way it's the bishop's oikonomia, his care for the household, that applies the canons to you. The Church hasn't settled which reading is right.
Your Baptist immersion isn't being graded either way. The question the Church is asking is whether the one baptism the Creed confesses has already happened, and it asks carefully because it can't happen twice. Bring the details of where and how you were baptized, and don't go shopping for the rite you'd prefer. How Converts Are Received lays out the history.
Sources: Ephesians 4:5 (NKJV). OCA, "Questions on the Sacraments," and the 1971 resolution of the ROCOR Council of Bishops, both as quoted on How Converts Are Received. Antiochian Archdiocese, approved service for the Chrismation of converts, preface on archdiocesan policy. Saint Basil, Letter 188, canon 1 (NPNF2 8). First Council of Constantinople (381), canon 7 (NPNF2 14).
Isn't the Lord's Supper just a memorial?
In much of the free-church world, yes: the Baptist Faith and Message calls it "a symbolic act of obedience" (art. VII). Reformed churches teach that believers feed on Christ "really and indeed, yet not carnally and corporally but spiritually" (Westminster 29.7). Lutherans confess that the Body and Blood "are truly present" (Augsburg, art. X). So "Protestant" already covers three different answers.
The Orthodox answer is the oldest one on record. Paul asks, "The cup of blessing which we bless, is it not the communion of the blood of Christ?" (1 Corinthians 10:16). Jesus says, "unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink His blood, you have no life in you" (John 6:53). Around 150, Saint Justin Martyr wrote that Christians don't receive it "as common bread and common drink" but as the flesh and blood of the incarnate Jesus. The Orthodox don't try to explain how. They pray for the Holy Spirit to change the gifts and then receive them with fear. And "remembrance" in the Liturgy is bigger than memory: the priest even "remembers" the Second Coming, which hasn't happened yet. Orthodox and Protestant, "Sacraments as mysteries," is the place to start.
Sources: Baptist Faith and Message (2000), art. VII. Westminster Confession 29.7. Augsburg Confession, art. X. 1 Corinthians 10:16; John 6:53 (NKJV). Saint Justin Martyr, First Apology 66 (ANF 1). Hapgood, Service Book, Divine Liturgy, p. 104.
Do you speak in tongues? Where are the gifts of the Spirit?
The Assemblies of God teach a baptism in the Holy Spirit after conversion, with speaking in tongues as its "initial physical sign" (Statement of Fundamental Truths, 7–8). The Orthodox don't teach a second baptism; they teach a seal. At chrismation, right after baptism, the priest anoints you and says at each touch, "The seal of the gift of the Holy Spirit." That's your Pentecost, and the gift doesn't depend on a sign.
The gifts themselves are real. Paul lists them (1 Corinthians 12), and the Church remembers saints who healed, prophesied and read hearts. Paul also asks, "Do all speak with tongues?" (1 Corinthians 12:30), and closes with "let all things be done decently and in order" (1 Corinthians 14:40). Saint John Chrysostom, in the fourth century, already called that chapter obscure because such gifts "used to occur but now no longer take place." The Orthodox spiritual tradition is cautious about chasing experiences and calls the counterfeit kind prelest (spiritual delusion). Baptism and Chrismation, "The seal," is the starting point.
Sources: Assemblies of God, Statement of Fundamental Truths, nos. 7–8. Hapgood, Service Book, Office of Holy Baptism, p. 282. 1 Corinthians 12:30; 14:40 (NKJV). Saint John Chrysostom, Homilies on 1 Corinthians 29 (NPNF1 12).
Doesn't putting images in worship break the regulative principle?
The Heidelberg Catechism puts your case plainly: God "can not and may not be visibly portrayed in any way," and images may not stand in churches in place of books for the unlearned, because God wants his people taught by "the living preaching of his Word" (Q&A 96–98). Westminster adds that God may not be worshiped "under any visible representation" (21.1).
The Orthodox agree with Heidelberg's first line: no one can paint the Father, or the divine nature. What they paint is the Son made flesh, "the image of the invisible God" (Colossians 1:15). And if worship must follow what God commanded, God commanded images for his own house: cherubim of gold over the Ark (Exodus 25:18), cherubim woven into the curtains (Exodus 26:1), and cherubim carved all over Solomon's Temple (1 Kings 6:29). The council of 787 drew the line where your catechism wants it: worship (latreia) to God alone, honor to the image, passing to the person shown.
You'll keep preaching. The Orthodox simply think the Word made flesh can be seen as well as heard. Icons makes the full case.
Sources: Heidelberg Catechism, Q&A 96–98. Westminster Confession 21.1. Colossians 1:15; Exodus 25:18; 26:1; 1 Kings 6:29 (NKJV). Second Council of Nicaea (787), definition (NPNF2 14).
Why pray for the dead? Isn't judgment fixed at death?
Westminster teaches that at death the righteous go to heaven and the wicked to hell, and "besides these two places… the Scripture acknowledgeth none" (32.1). The Thirty-Nine Articles reject the Roman doctrine of purgatory (art. XXII). Many Anglicans, though, still pray for the departed.
The Orthodox agree that "it is appointed for men to die once, but after this the judgment" (Hebrews 9:27), and they don't teach purgatory. They pray for the dead because love doesn't stop at a grave and the Church hasn't stopped either: Judas Maccabeus made an offering for his fallen soldiers (2 Maccabees 12:43–45), and Christians were praying for the departed at the Eucharist long before there were confessions; Saint Cyril of Jerusalem describes it around 350. Many readers, ancient and modern, take Paul's words for Onesiphorus ("the Lord grant to him that he may find mercy from the Lord in that Day," 2 Timothy 1:18) as such a prayer.
Orthodox teaching also says that repentance belongs to this life and that there is no repentance after death. The Church holds both, the call to repent before we die and the prayer for the dead after it, without explaining how they fit. This is the tension in the teaching as received. The Church doesn't claim to map how God uses those prayers. It just keeps praying until the last Day. What Happens After Death? sets out what the Church says and where it stays quiet.
Sources: Westminster Confession 32.1. Thirty-Nine Articles, art. XXII. Book of Common Prayer (1979), Burial of the Dead: Rite Two. Hebrews 9:27; 2 Timothy 1:18 (NKJV). 2 Maccabees 12:43–45. Saint Cyril of Jerusalem, Mystagogical Catecheses 5.9 (NPNF2 7). Saint John of Damascus, Exposition of the Orthodox Faith II.4 (NPNF2 9).
Do we 'sleep' when we die?
No. The Orthodox Church doesn't teach "soul sleep," the idea that the dead are unconscious until the resurrection. At death the soul is separated from the body, but it remains conscious and alive in God. Paul says he's "well pleased rather to be absent from the body and to be present with the Lord" (2 Corinthians 5:8), and that he has "a desire to depart and be with Christ, which is far better" (Philippians 1:23). Jesus tells the thief on the cross, "today you will be with Me in Paradise" (Luke 23:43), not after a long sleep. And at the Transfiguration, Moses and Elijah are talking with him about the death he was about to accomplish (Luke 9:30–31).
Scripture does sometimes call death "falling asleep," and the services use the word too. It's a word of hope. Paul writes about "those who have fallen asleep" so that you won't "sorrow as others who have no hope" (1 Thessalonians 4:13), and in the Liturgy the priest prays for those "who have fallen asleep in the hope of Resurrection unto life eternal." The sleep language refers to the body awaiting the resurrection, not to the soul going unconscious: death isn't the end, because we will be raised (1 Corinthians 15:51–52).
That's also why the Church prays for the departed. They're alive in Christ, and the Church is one family on both sides of death. Our fulfillment comes at the general resurrection, when soul and body are reunited. The Synod of Jerusalem in 1672 said that the souls of the departed go at once either to joy or to sorrow, though neither their enjoyment nor their condemnation is yet complete. Beyond that the Church is deliberately quiet about the details of the in-between. What Happens After Death? sets out where it speaks plainly and where it stays reverent.
Sources: 2 Corinthians 5:8; Philippians 1:23; Luke 23:43; Luke 9:30–31; 1 Thessalonians 4:13; 1 Corinthians 15:51–52 (NKJV). Hapgood, Service Book, Divine Liturgy, p. 90 ("lie asleep in the Lord") and p. 107 ("fallen asleep in the hope of Resurrection unto life eternal"). Confession of Dositheus (Jerusalem, 1672), Decree 18, a local synod and not an ecumenical council.
Questions from Protestants and Anglicans
We Lutherans have the real presence and private absolution. What's the difference?
Less than with most Protestants, and you're right to notice. Augsburg confesses that the Body and Blood "are truly present" (art. X) and that private absolution "ought to be retained" (art. XI). Lutherans also baptize infants, keep a liturgy, and often keep the church year.
The differences sit underneath. The Orthodox offer the Eucharist as a sacrifice ("Thine own, of thine own, we offer unto thee"). Augsburg's article on the Mass objects to one understanding of sacrifice, the idea that the Mass "takes away the sins of the living and the dead by the outward act" (art. XXIV). The Orthodox don't define the presence with Lutheran formulas like "under the bread, with the bread, in the bread"; they pray for the Spirit to change the gifts and leave the how unexplained. Ordination is a sacrament received from bishops in succession; the Lutheran confessions treat church order differently. And the Orthodox ask the saints to pray for them, where Augsburg says "the Scripture teaches not the invocation of saints" (art. XXI).
In 1906 the Russian Church in North America received Lutherans by chrismation, after they renounced specific points. Most American jurisdictions still receive baptized Lutherans that way, by the bishop's decision. Orthodox and Protestant gives the wider frame.
Sources: Augsburg Confession, arts. X, XI, XXI, XXIV. Formula of Concord, Solid Declaration VII.35. Hapgood, Service Book, Divine Liturgy, p. 105; Office for the Reception of Converts, pp. 454–467.
Councils can err. Why should I trust yours?
Your confessions say so outright. Westminster: "All synods or councils since the apostles' times… may err, and many have erred" (31.4 in the 1647 text; 31.3 in the American revision). The Thirty-Nine Articles: councils "may err, and sometimes have erred, even in things pertaining unto God" (art. XXI).
The surprise is that the Orthodox agree councils can err. The "Robber Council" of Ephesus in 449 and the iconoclast council of 754 both met as ecumenical councils, and the Church threw both out. A council isn't trusted because it met. It's trusted because the whole Church, over time, received its teaching as the faith it already held; in 1848 the Eastern patriarchs wrote that "the protector of religion is the very body of the Church, even the people themselves."
So the real disagreement isn't about councils. It's about whether Christ's promise that the Spirit "will guide you into all truth" (John 16:13) belongs to the Church as a body, or only to Scripture read by each believer. How the Church Is Organized, "Bishops and synods," shows how decisions get made.
Sources: Westminster Confession 31.4 (1647) / 31.3 (American). Thirty-Nine Articles, art. XXI. Encyclical of the Eastern Patriarchs (1848), §17. On 449 and 754: rejected at Chalcedon (451) and the Second Council of Nicaea (787). John 16:13 (NKJV).
Didn't a patriarch once sign a Calvinist confession?
Yes, and it's a real story. Cyril Lucaris, patriarch of Constantinople, had a Confession of Faith published at Geneva in 1629 that read much like Reformed theology on Scripture, justification and predestination. Some Orthodox have since argued it wasn't entirely his work; the question is still debated. Cyril was killed by the Ottoman authorities in 1638.
What the Church did next is the point. Synods at Constantinople (1638), Iași (1642) and Jerusalem (1672) condemned the confession's teaching, and the Jerusalem synod answered it article by article in the Confession of Dositheus. A generation earlier, Patriarch Jeremias II had corresponded with Lutheran theologians at Tübingen (1575–81) and declined their invitation, politely and in detail.
So the Orthodox didn't miss the Reformation. They read it, argued with it from Scripture and the Fathers, and said no. You can respect that answer without accepting it. Orthodox and Protestant, "Where it came from," gives the larger setting.
Sources: Encyclopaedia Britannica, "Cyril Lucaris." Confession of Dositheus (Jerusalem, 1672), Decrees 1–18. Wikipedia, "Cyril Lucaris" (the synods of 1638, 1642 and 1672) and "Jeremias II of Constantinople" (the Tübingen exchange).
Isn't Anglicanism already catholic and orthodox enough?
You have more in common with the Orthodox than most Protestants do: bishops, creeds, a prayer book, the church year, and a long friendship. Anglicans and Orthodox have been in formal dialogue since the 1970s, and before that the Fellowship of Saint Alban and Saint Sergius, which grew out of Anglo-Russian student conferences in 1927 and 1928, brought the two together. The Lambeth Quadrilateral names your four essentials: Scripture, the Apostles' and Nicene Creeds, baptism and the Eucharist, and the historic episcopate.
The Orthodox would point to what your own Articles say. Article XIX holds that the churches of "Jerusalem, Alexandria, and Antioch" have erred, which an Antiochian can't help noticing. Article XXI says councils "may err." Articles XXII and XXV reject the invocation of saints and treat only two sacraments as "of the Gospel." And the filioque is still in the Creed in many Anglican prayer books, though Lambeth has recommended dropping it. The ordination of women and other recent decisions have made the dialogue harder.
So the Orthodox answer is warm but clear: close, and not the same. Orthodox and Protestant is the nearest page.
Sources: Thirty-Nine Articles, arts. XIX, XXI (1571 text), XXII, XXV. Lambeth Conference 1888, Resolution 11 (the Lambeth Quadrilateral). Lambeth Conference 1978, Resolution 35. Fellowship of St Alban and St Sergius, "History."
Would you recognize my Anglican baptism? My ordination?
Baptism first. If you were baptized with water in the name of the Trinity, many bishops in America would receive you by chrismation, after a first confession; some baptize. Your bishop decides, and How Converts Are Received explains the range.
Orders are different. In 1922 the Ecumenical Patriarchate's synod issued an encyclical favorable to the validity of Anglican orders, and Jerusalem, Cyprus, Alexandria, Romania and Greece issued statements of their own between 1923 and 1939. Those statements were never received by the whole Orthodox Church, and they were written before the ordination of women changed the Anglican picture. In current practice, Anglican clergy who become Orthodox priests are ordained, not received in their orders.
That isn't a verdict on your ministry or on the grace God has worked through it. It's a statement that the Orthodox can only ordain within their own communion. If you're a priest thinking about this, the conversation belongs with an Orthodox bishop, early.
Sources: Ecumenical Patriarchate, Encyclical on Anglican Orders (1922); statements of Jerusalem (1923), Cyprus (1923), Alexandria (1930), Romania (1936) and Greece (1939), as collected by Project Canterbury. Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia, Diocese of Great Britain and Western Europe, "Ordinations." How Converts Are Received.
Questions from Catholics
My Church says I'm allowed to receive at an Orthodox Liturgy. Why can't I?
You're not imagining it. Catholic law lets a Catholic receive from ministers of churches whose sacraments Rome regards as valid, when necessity or real spiritual benefit calls for it and a Catholic priest can't be reached (Code of Canon Law, can. 844 §2). The Catechism goes further and says some sharing with the Orthodox, "given suitable circumstances and the approval of Church authority, is not merely possible but is encouraged" (CCC 1399).
That's a permission your Church gives you. It can't open someone else's chalice. Catholic ecumenical norms themselves tell a Catholic to respect Eastern discipline and to refrain from receiving "if that Church restricts sacramental communion to its own members to the exclusion of others" (Directory on Ecumenism, 1993, §124). For the Orthodox, sharing the cup is the sign of a unity that already exists in faith and Church, and the papacy and other questions are still open between the two churches. "The Eucharist is the result of unity, not the means by which unity is achieved," as an OCA answer puts it.
It stings more for you than for almost anyone, because your Church believes what the Orthodox believe about that cup. The Orthodox know that. Can I Take Communion? explains what to do when the line forms.
Sources: Code of Canon Law, can. 844 §2. CCC 1399. Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, Directory for the Application of Principles and Norms on Ecumenism (1993), §124. OCA, "Receiving Communion," as quoted on Can I Take Communion?
Do you think our sacraments are real? Is my baptism valid?
Your Church has a clear answer about ours: it says the Orthodox "possess true sacraments, above all… the priesthood and the Eucharist" (CCC 1399), and that the communion between us "lacks little" (CCC 838). It's fair to ask whether the Orthodox return the compliment. The honest answer is that they don't have one answer.
The two churches share the same structures and vocabulary: bishops, priests, seven named mysteries, the early councils. How Catholic sacraments should be regarded is argued inside Orthodoxy. A more generous camp, in Kallistos Ware's description, says "we know where the Church is but we cannot be sure where it is not." A stricter camp holds that those outside Orthodoxy are outside the Church, while still leaving the sincere to God's mercy. The way converts are received shows the split: many bishops receive Catholics by chrismation, some baptize them, and the Church hasn't settled it.
What every Orthodox Christian can say is what they know about their own Church, and that judging your soul is God's business. How Converts Are Received maps the practice; Orthodox and Catholic covers the rest.
Sources: CCC 838, 1399. Ware, The Orthodox Church, ch. 16, "The Orthodox Church and the Reunion of Christians." How Converts Are Received; Hapgood, Service Book, pp. 454–467.
Do you believe in the Assumption?
Catholic dogma, defined by Pius XII in 1950, holds that Mary, "having completed the course of her earthly life, was assumed body and soul into heavenly glory" (Munificentissimus Deus 44; see CCC 966). The definition doesn't say whether she died first.
The Orthodox keep the same day, August 15, under a different name: the Dormition, her "falling asleep." It isn't a defined dogma, and it doesn't need to be. The Church sings her death, her burial and her passing over into life every year, after two weeks of fasting, and faithful Orthodox Christians accept it whole. Where Rome often defines, the East prays, and the prayer carries the faith.
So an Orthodox Christian will sing on August 15 that neither tomb nor death could hold the Mother of Life, and you'd recognize most of what you hear. The disagreement is less about Mary than about whether a pope can make such a teaching binding on the whole Church. Mary and the Saints and the Dormition of the Theotokos page cover the feast.
Sources: Pius XII, Munificentissimus Deus (1950), 44. CCC 966. Kontakion of the Dormition (OCA translation), paraphrased.
What do you do with Matthew 16, 'on this rock'?
Here's the text: "And I also say to you that you are Peter, and on this rock I will build My church, and the gates of Hades shall not prevail against it" (Matthew 16:18). Your Catechism reads it this way: "The Lord made Simon alone, whom he named Peter, the 'rock' of his Church" (CCC 881), and it grounds the pope's office in that commission.
The Orthodox honor Peter as first of the apostles and don't explain the verse away. They notice that the Fathers read "this rock" more than one way: as Peter's confession of faith (Saint John Chrysostom), as Peter himself, and as Christ (Saint Augustine). Saint Cyprian, who read it of Peter, still taught that "the episcopate is one, each part of which is held by each one for the whole." And the power to bind and loose that Jesus gives Peter in chapter 16 he gives all the apostles two chapters later (Matthew 18:18).
So both churches agree Peter matters enormously. They disagree about whether his primacy passes to one bishop with authority over the whole Church. Orthodox and Catholic, "The papacy," sets out both positions.
Sources: Matthew 16:18; 18:18 (NKJV). Catechism of the Catholic Church 881. Saint John Chrysostom, Homilies on Matthew 54.3 (NPNF1 10). Saint Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John 124.5 (NPNF1 7). Saint Cyprian, On the Unity of the Church 4–5 (ANF 5).
I'm Byzantine Catholic. Same Liturgy. What's actually different?
Walk into an Orthodox church and you'll know every hymn. Your church and the Orthodox share the Liturgy, the calendar, married priests and much of the spirituality. The difference is communion. Your church is in full communion with Rome and accepts its teaching, including the papacy as Vatican I defined it, the Immaculate Conception and the Assumption, even where your parish's piety expresses them in Eastern ways. The Orthodox aren't in communion with Rome and don't receive those definitions. (On the Assumption the gap is smaller than it sounds: the Orthodox sing much the same thing on August 15 and accept it fully; they just don't hold it as a defined dogma.)
The history hurts on both sides. Most Eastern Catholic churches came from Orthodox communities that entered union with Rome, at Brest in 1596 and Uzhhorod in 1646 among others. In 1993 the official Catholic-Orthodox commission, at Balamand, agreed that "uniatism" can no longer be the model for unity, while affirming the Eastern Catholic churches' right to exist.
Which is why the Orthodox call you the best evidence that the pope isn't the only difference. Who Are the Orthodox?, "The neighbors people confuse," has the rest.
Sources: Union of Brest (1596) and Union of Uzhhorod (1646), as cited on Who Are the Orthodox? Joint International Commission for Theological Dialogue between the Catholic Church and the Orthodox Church, Balamand Statement (1993), §§3, 12.
Do the Orthodox believe in transubstantiation?
Yes and no, and the "no" is smaller than people think. Trent says the change of bread and wine into Christ's Body and Blood is fittingly called transubstantiation (CCC 1376). The Orthodox believe the change just as firmly. In the Liturgy the priest asks God to "send thy Holy Spirit upon us, and upon these Gifts here spread forth," and to make the bread and wine the Body and Blood of Christ, "transmuting them by thy Holy Spirit." The Greek word for that change is metabole.
Some Orthodox texts have used the Greek equivalent of transubstantiation (metousiosis), notably the Confession of Dositheus in 1672. Many Orthodox theologians would rather not tie the mystery to the philosophy of substance and accidents. Saint John of Damascus, in the eighth century, gave the classic Orthodox shrug: if you ask how it happens, it's enough to know that it's through the Holy Spirit.
The Orthodox also place the consecrating moment at the invocation of the Spirit (the epiclesis), not only at the words of institution. Words of Institution and Epiclesis covers the moment itself.
Sources: Catechism of the Catholic Church 1376. Divine Liturgy of Saint John Chrysostom, epiclesis, in Hapgood, Service Book, pp. 105–106. Confession of Dositheus (Synod of Jerusalem, 1672), Decree 17. Saint John of Damascus, Exposition of the Orthodox Faith IV.13 (NPNF2 9).
Is reunion coming? Aren't we 'sister Churches'?
The relationship is far warmer than it was a century ago. In 1965 Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras lifted the excommunications of 1054. An official theological commission has met since 1980 and has spent recent years on the hardest question, primacy (Ravenna 2007, Chieti 2016). Popes and ecumenical patriarchs pray together publicly now. Your Catechism says the communion between our churches "lacks little" (CCC 838).
"Sister Churches" is used on both sides, though each means something careful by it. A 2000 Vatican note says the Catholic Church as a whole is not the sister but the mother of particular churches. And many Orthodox are wary of the phrase because it can suggest that the questions are already solved.
They aren't. The papacy, the filioque and the dogmas defined in the West since the split are still open, and Orthodoxy has its own internal divisions to heal first. No date is set, and nobody serious will promise one. Pray for it anyway. Orthodox and Catholic, "Where it came from," takes the story to 1965.
Sources: Paul VI and Athenagoras I, Joint Catholic-Orthodox Declaration (December 7, 1965). Catechism of the Catholic Church 838. Joint International Commission for Theological Dialogue between the Catholic Church and the Orthodox Church: first plenary, Patmos–Rhodes (1980); Ravenna Document (2007); Chieti Document (2016). Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Note on the Expression "Sister Churches" (2000), §10.
The Church, ecumenism and the world
Why won't you ordain women? My pastor is a woman.
Your church isn't alone. The Episcopal Church has ordained women priests since 1976, and the ELCA, the Presbyterian Church (USA) and the United Methodists ordain women too. Others don't: the Catholic Church holds that only a baptized man can receive ordination (CCC 1577), and the Baptist Faith and Message limits "the office of pastor… to men as qualified by Scripture" (art. VI).
The Orthodox Church has never ordained women as priests or bishops. The reasons usually given are that Christ chose twelve men and the Church has received that choice as binding, and that the priest at the altar stands as an icon of Christ the Bridegroom. Some Orthodox theologians have called the question less settled than it looks; the Church's practice hasn't changed.
What it isn't is a ranking of souls. The first person the Church honors is a woman, the first witnesses of the Resurrection were women, and the Church once had ordained deaconesses, an order some Orthodox are working to revive. Women in the Church sets this out honestly.
Sources: Catechism of the Catholic Church 1577. Baptist Faith and Message (2000), art. VI. Episcopal Church, General Convention (1976). Kallistos Ware, "Man, Woman and the Priesthood of Christ," in Thomas Hopko, ed., Women and the Priesthood (SVS Press, 1999), p. 7. Fiona André, "Eastern Orthodox Church ordains Zimbabwean woman as its first deaconess," Religion News Service, via Episcopal News Service (May 6, 2024).
Where does your church stand on gay people and same-sex marriage?
Many mainline churches have changed their teaching. The Episcopal Church authorized same-sex marriage rites in 2015; in 2024 the United Methodists removed their bans on gay clergy and on same-sex weddings. The Orthodox Church hasn't changed. In 2013 the Orthodox bishops of North America stated jointly that marriage is "the union of a man and a woman," and that acting on any sexual attraction outside marriage, "heterosexual or homosexual," alienates us from God.
Notice the second half. The standard is the same for everyone: chastity outside marriage, faithfulness within it. A single straight man is asked exactly what a single gay man is asked, and both will struggle with it.
You'll find gay and same-sex-attracted Orthodox Christians in parishes, praying, fasting and confessing like everyone else. Anyone may attend every service. Questions about receiving Communion, or about your own life, belong in a private conversation with the priest, and the bishops themselves sent people there. Marriage and the Crowning gives the Church's theology of marriage.
Sources: Assembly of Canonical Orthodox Bishops of North and Central America, Statement on Marriage and Sexuality (September 2013), §§2, 3, 5. United Methodist General Conference (2024). Episcopal Church, General Convention (2015), Resolutions A036 and A054.
Isn't Orthodoxy a bunker for conservatives fleeing church fights?
Some converts do arrive bruised from a denominational fight, and it's fair to ask whether they came for Christ or for a hiding place. Good priests ask the same question, which is one reason the catechumenate often takes about a year. An old rule still applies: "it is not the length of time, but the course of life, that is judged."
Two cautions. First, Orthodoxy isn't conflict-free. It argues about the calendar, about how to receive converts, and, since 2018, about the Church in Ukraine. You won't escape church politics by changing churches. Second, people who come to the Orthodox Church to win an argument usually lose interest when they find it wants their pride more than their opinions. The Guide's own warning about "convert zeal" is aimed right here.
The good reason to come is the one the Church gives: Christ, the Liturgy, and the life of repentance. If that's what draws you, the politics will matter less with every year. The Path In and The First Year After Reception say how that works.
Sources: Apostolic Constitutions VIII.32 (ANF 7), as quoted on The Path In. The Path In, on the length of the catechumenate and on convert zeal.
Are you even ecumenical? Are you in the World Council of Churches?
More than people expect. In 1920 the Ecumenical Patriarchate sent an encyclical "unto the Churches of Christ everywhere" calling for a fellowship of churches, years before the World Council of Churches existed. Some Orthodox churches were among the WCC's founding members, and in time all of them joined. Georgia withdrew in 1997 and Bulgaria in 1998.
What the Orthodox mean by ecumenism is specific. They pray with other Christians, talk theology with them, work alongside them, and don't share Communion with them, because for the Orthodox the cup is the sign of unity already given. The WCC's own Toronto Statement (1950) says membership doesn't require any church to treat the others as churches in the full sense. The Orthodox signed on under exactly that understanding, and the 2016 Council of Crete restated it.
So you'll meet Orthodox Christians at ecumenical services and in shared charitable work. You won't see them at an open table. Can I Take Communion? explains why.
Sources: Ecumenical Patriarchate, "Unto the Churches of Christ Everywhere" (1920). WCC Central Committee, "The Church, the Churches and the World Council of Churches" (Toronto Statement, 1950), IV.4. Holy and Great Council (Crete, 2016), "Relations of the Orthodox Church with the Rest of the Christian World."
Can Orthodox and Coptic Christians receive Communion together?
No. We aren't in communion with the Copts, so Communion isn't shared either way; ask your priest.
Sources: Field Guide page Who Are the Orthodox?.
Isn't Orthodoxy tied up with Russian nationalism?
The Orthodox Church isn't one national church. It's a family of self-governing churches, Greek, Antiochian, Serbian, Romanian, Russian and more, and in 1872 a council at Constantinople condemned organizing the Church by race or nationality (phyletism).
The question usually comes from the news. A dispute over the Church in Ukraine has divided some Orthodox churches from one another since 2018, and the war has made it sharper. The Guide doesn't take a side, and it doesn't treat any one national church as the whole Church.
In an American parish you'll mostly meet people who care about Christ, the Liturgy and the coffee. How the Church Is Organized explains how the jurisdictions here fit together, and Myth: "Orthodoxy is an ethnic church" explains phyletism.
Sources: Council of Constantinople (1872), as cited on Myth: "Orthodoxy is an ethnic church."
Skeptics and seekers
Why do I need a church? I'm spiritual, not religious.
You may have good reasons. Maybe a church hurt you, or bored you, or felt like a club with dues. The Orthodox won't argue you out of any of that.
What they'll say is that their faith is built on a God who didn't stay spiritual. He took a body, cooked fish on a beach, and left his friends bread and wine instead of a set of ideas. So Orthodox spirituality is stubbornly physical: you stand, bow, smell incense, kiss icons and taste the Eucharist, and it all happens with other people. Saint John says it bluntly: "he who does not love his brother whom he has seen, how can he love God whom he has not seen?" (1 John 4:20). A spirituality you keep to yourself never has to forgive anyone.
You don't have to sign anything to find out what that's like. Come to Vespers on a Saturday night. Stand where you're comfortable. The Guide calls the Church a hospital, and nobody at a hospital asks if you're spiritual enough to come in. Who Are the Orthodox? is a good first page.
Sources: John 21:9–13; 1 John 4:20 (NKJV). The Christian Life, on the Church as a hospital.
Aren't all religions basically saying the same thing?
They overlap more than some Christians admit. Saint Justin Martyr, around 150, taught that the Word of God had sown seeds of truth in every people, so that "whatever things were rightly said among all men, are the property of us Christians." When an Orthodox Christian hears wisdom from a Buddhist or a Stoic, he doesn't have to pretend he didn't.
But they don't say the same thing about the center. The Creed makes specific claims about history: that God became a man, was crucified "under Pontius Pilate," and rose on the third day. Islam honors Jesus as the Messiah and a messenger of God and denies the crucifixion; Judaism awaits a Messiah; Buddhism doesn't speak of a personal Creator at all. Saying they all agree takes every one of them less seriously than its believers do.
The Orthodox would rather respect the differences and then tell you plainly what they believe. You're free to disagree. The Orthodox, Judaism, and Islam shows how that looks with the two nearest neighbors.
Sources: Saint Justin Martyr, Second Apology 13 (ANF 1), as quoted on Orthodox and Protestant. Qur'an 4:157, as cited on The Orthodox, Judaism, and Islam. The Creed, as printed on The Creed in Plain Words.
How can a good God allow suffering?
The Orthodox don't have a neat answer, and they distrust anyone who does. Job's friends had neat answers, and God rebuked them.
What the Church offers isn't an argument but a person. When his friend Lazarus died, "Jesus wept" (John 11:35), even though he was about to raise him. God didn't explain suffering from a distance; he walked into it, was tortured and executed, and broke death open from the inside. The Church treats death as an enemy, not a lesson, and it promises a day when God "will wipe away every tear from their eyes; there shall be no more death" (Revelation 21:4). In the fourth century, Saint Basil preached a whole sermon arguing that God is not the author of evil.
If you're asking because you're grieving, the Church's funerals and memorial services sing grief out loud, and anyone may come. If you're asking as a skeptic, the question is a fair one, and Dostoevsky put it more sharply than most atheists have. What Happens After Death? is the closest page.
Sources: Job 42:7; John 11:35; Revelation 21:4 (NKJV). Saint Basil the Great, "Homily Explaining That God Is Not the Cause of Evil," in On the Human Condition, trans. Nonna Verna Harrison (SVS Press, 2005). Fyodor Dostoevsky, The Brothers Karamazov, bk. 5, ch. 4, "Rebellion."
Does the Orthodox Church reject evolution?
The Creed says God made all things; it doesn't say how or how long, and no ecumenical council has ruled on evolution. Orthodox Christians disagree about evolution and the age of the earth. Father Seraphim Rose argued against evolution in Genesis, Creation and Early Man. Theodosius Dobzhansky, one of the founders of modern genetics, was a practicing Orthodox Christian who wrote "Nothing in Biology Makes Sense Except in the Light of Evolution" (1973). Both are honest Orthodox positions, and the Guide won't pick a winner.
What the Church does teach is that God made everything freely, out of nothing, "Maker of heaven and earth, And of all things visible and invisible"; that creation is good; and that human beings bear God's image. Saint Basil's sermons on the six days of creation drew on the natural science of his day, and the Church never made that science part of the faith.
So you don't have to choose between the Liturgy and a biology textbook. You may meet Orthodox Christians who think you should, on either side. The Creed in Plain Words, "One God, the Father," covers what the Church actually confesses.
Sources: The Creed, as printed on The Creed in Plain Words. Seraphim Rose, Genesis, Creation and Early Man (2000). Theodosius Dobzhansky, "Nothing in Biology Makes Sense Except in the Light of Evolution," The American Biology Teacher 35, no. 3 (March 1973): 125–129. Saint Basil the Great, Hexaemeron 1.10 (NPNF2 8).
Didn't Constantine invent Jesus' divinity and pick the Bible?
The Bible half is a myth, and the Guide already debunks it: Nicaea in 325 never listed the books of the Bible, and the first surviving list of our twenty-seven New Testament books comes from Saint Athanasius in 367.
The divinity half is a myth too. Long before Constantine, Thomas calls the risen Jesus "My Lord and my God!" (John 20:28). Saint Ignatius of Antioch, on his way to martyrdom around 107, calls Jesus "our God." Around 112, a Roman governor, Pliny, reported to the emperor that Christians met before dawn to sing a hymn "to Christ as to a god." What Nicaea did was answer Arius, a priest who taught that the Son was a created being, with the word homoousios: the Son is of one essence with the Father. Constantine called the council. The bishops wrote the Creed, and the argument went on until the Council of Constantinople in 381, long after Constantine had died, which isn't what an emperor's invention looks like.
Myth: "The Council of Nicea picked the books of the Bible" and The Creed in Plain Words have the details.
Sources: John 20:28 (NKJV). Saint Ignatius of Antioch, To the Ephesians 18 (ANF 1). Pliny the Younger, Letters 10.96. Eusebius, Life of Constantine III.6; IV.64 (NPNF2 1). Saint Athanasius, Festal Letter 39, as cited on Myth: "The Council of Nicea picked the books of the Bible." Arius, homoousios and the Council of Constantinople (381), as set out on The Creed in Plain Words.
Do you think I'm going to hell for not believing?
No Orthodox Christian is authorized to tell you where you'll spend eternity. Judgment belongs to Christ, and he published the exam in advance: whether you fed the hungry, welcomed the stranger, clothed the naked, and visited the sick and the prisoner (Matthew 25:35–36). Saint Paul writes that Gentiles who never had the Law can still show "the work of the law written in their hearts" (Romans 2:15).
The Orthodox are sure where the Church is and much more careful about where God's mercy isn't. They hold that Christ is the way to the Father, and that the Word has sown seeds of truth in every people. They also don't pretend the stakes are low. Jesus speaks of everlasting punishment and eternal life (Matthew 25:46), and the Church prays for everyone without teaching that everyone is certain to be saved.
So the honest answer is that the Church doesn't know your outcome, wants you to know Christ, and won't threaten you into it. The Field Note on Orthodox and Protestant and What Happens After Death? go further.
Sources: Matthew 25:35–36, 46; Romans 2:15 (NKJV). Saint Justin Martyr, Second Apology 13, as quoted on Orthodox and Protestant. Metropolitan Kallistos Ware's two camps, as described on Orthodox and Protestant.
Can I come if I don't believe any of it? Will people try to convert me?
Yes, you can come, and no, nobody will corner you. The Divine Liturgy is public. Stand where you're comfortable, slip in the back if you need to, sit when you're tired, and watch. Nobody checks your beliefs at the door and nobody asks you to come forward at the end.
There's one boundary. Communion is for Orthodox Christians, so when the line forms, stay where you are; at the end you're welcome to go up for the blessed bread, which isn't Communion. Many of the people in that line once stood where you're standing, some of them as skeptics.
If someone at coffee hour gets too eager, it's usually a recent convert, and you're allowed to change the subject. The Church's own approach is slow on purpose: inquiring costs nothing, and even serious inquirers spend a year or so before anything formal happens. "Come and see" (John 1:46) is still the whole invitation. Can I Take Communion?, "What you do," covers the one moment that's reserved.
Sources: John 1:46 (NKJV). Can I Take Communion?, "What you do"; The Path In.
Why trust a church with its own scandals?
You shouldn't trust any church because it claims to be holy. The Orthodox Church has had its share of sin, including clergy who abused their office, and pretending otherwise would make your question more urgent, not less.
The Church's own law is severe about clergy who sin gravely: the ancient canons depose them, and the Church has long held that a priest's sin doesn't make the sacraments false but does disqualify him from serving. In America, jurisdictions such as the Orthodox Church in America publish binding policies on sexual misconduct that require reporting. If you or someone you love has been harmed, go to the civil authorities and to the diocese; you owe no institution your silence.
Why trust it at all? The Orthodox would say don't trust it the way you trust a brand. Christ's harshest words were for religious people who used God as cover (Matthew 23). The Church is a hospital full of patients, some of them clergy, and the medicine is still real. Who Are the Orthodox? describes how it's structured and who answers to whom.
Sources: Apostolic Canon 25 (NPNF2 14). Orthodox Church in America, Policies, Standards, and Procedures of the Orthodox Church in America on Sexual Misconduct (2014), sec. 8. Matthew 23 (NKJV).
Family and practical questions
Will I have to change my name?
Not on your driver's license. Your legal name stays exactly as it is.
What you'll receive is a Christian name, a saint's name, used in the Church's prayers: at baptism or chrismation, at confession, at your wedding, and at the chalice ("The servant of God, N., partaketh…"). If your name is already a saint's name (Michael, Mary, Elizabeth, Stephen), you'll usually keep it and take that saint as your patron. If it isn't, you and your priest choose a saint, sometimes one whose name sounds like yours, sometimes one whose life you love. Customs differ by tradition and by parish, so ask your priest about yours.
You might end up answering to "Photini" at the chalice and "Tiffany" at work, and that's normal. Your saint's feast becomes your name day, and in many Orthodox families it outranks your birthday. The Path In, "You choose a patron saint," and Family Life, Name Days, and Godparents cover it.
Sources: Hapgood, Service Book, p. 119. The Path In; Family Life, Name Days, and Godparents.
My spouse isn't Orthodox. What happens to our marriage?
If you're already married, your marriage stays your marriage. Becoming Orthodox doesn't dissolve it, and nobody will ask your spouse to convert or leave. Saint Paul answered this for the Corinthians: "the unbelieving husband is sanctified by the wife, and the unbelieving wife is sanctified by the husband" (1 Corinthians 7:14). When someone comes into the Church already married, their reception fills in whatever was lacking in the other sacraments, and the marriage is typically accepted with no extra step required. While many do end up receiving the blessing of the Church on their marriage after their reception, by no means is this universally done. Marriage for Orthodox Christians should always be blessed in the Church and in accordance with both canonical norms and civil law.
Your spouse is welcome at every service, can stand beside you, and can come up for the blessed bread at the end. They won't receive Communion. Don't make them your project; Saint Peter's advice to wives with unbelieving husbands was to win them "without a word" (1 Peter 3:1).
If you're not married yet, the canons are strict. Trullo forbids an Orthodox to marry a non-Orthodox, and bishops, in their care for the household (oikonomia), bless marriage to a baptized Christian by petition, couple by couple, in an Orthodox church; the canon stays the norm. Marriage to a non-Christian isn't permitted under the OCA New York–New Jersey guidelines, for example; other jurisdictions publish their own. Marriage and the Crowning, "Mixed marriages," has the details.
Sources: 1 Corinthians 7:14; 1 Peter 3:1 (NKJV). Council in Trullo, canon 72 (NPNF2 14). OCA Diocese of New York and New Jersey, Concerning Marriage (2016), as cited on Marriage and the Crowning.
Can my Methodist sister be my baby's godmother?
No, the sponsor must be Orthodox. The reason isn't about her. At an Orthodox baptism the godparent says the Creed aloud for the child, renounces Satan on the child's behalf, and promises to help raise the child Orthodox. The person making those promises must actually belong to the Orthodox Church.
The sponsor answers for the child's Orthodox faith, so the Church requires an Orthodox Christian. The Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America states it plainly: a person who sponsors a candidate for Baptism or Chrismation "must be an Orthodox Christian in good standing and a supporting member of an Orthodox parish." Your sister can't take that role, and that says nothing against her faith or her love for your child.
There are other ways to honor her: invite her to the baptism and the meal afterward, ask her to pray for your child by name, make her the aunt who shows up on name days. Love doesn't need a liturgical role to count. Baptism and Chrismation, "What you do," explains what a godparent actually does.
Sources: Hapgood, Service Book, p. 602, as cited on Baptism and Chrismation. Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America, "Instructions for Weddings, Divorces, Baptisms, Funerals, and Memorials," Baptisms.
If I convert, what happens with my kids? My teenager?
It depends on their ages and on them. Young children usually come in with their parents: an unbaptized child is baptized and chrismated, a child already baptized as a Christian is received as the bishop directs, often by chrismation, and from then on they receive Communion like everyone else, infants included. Bringing Kids explains why the Orthodox give babies Communion.
Older children and teenagers are a different conversation. A teenager is old enough to have a faith of their own, and a good priest will want to hear it from the teenager, not just from Mom. Many priests will catechize a teen alongside a parent or separately, at the teen's pace, and some teens wait. That's not failure. Bring them to Vespers and the Liturgy, answer their questions honestly, let them see you pray, and don't make the Church a battlefield at home.
How your children are received is the priest's and bishop's decision, worked out with you. Bringing Kids and Baptism and Chrismation cover the younger years; The Path In covers adults.
Sources: Bringing Kids; Baptism and Chrismation; How Converts Are Received; The Path In.
My family thinks I'm leaving Jesus. What do I tell them?
Start by hearing what they're afraid of, because it's usually love. Your evangelical parents may fear you've traded Jesus for rituals and saints. Your Catholic mother may fear you've left the Church of your baptism. Neither is a silly fear, and neither is helped by winning an argument at Thanksgiving.
Then tell them what you found, not what's wrong with them. "I'm not leaving Jesus. I'm going deeper into the Church that's prayed to him since the apostles." If they ask about Mary or icons or purgatory, you can answer one question at a time, and the Guide has pages for most of them. Honor your father and mother, even when they're angry; that commandment didn't expire when you were chrismated.
Invite them to a service, without pressure, and let the Liturgy speak. Don't send them a reading list. And give it time. Plenty of frightened families end up standing in the back at the reception. Orthodox and Protestant and Orthodox and Catholic, "What you do," show how to talk across the line.
Sources: Exodus 20:12 (NKJV).
Can I still go to my family's church for Christmas, weddings, funerals?
Usually, yes, to be there. Many priests in American parishes expect you to attend a sibling's wedding, a grandparent's funeral, or Christmas Eve with your family when love calls for it. What you don't do there is receive Communion; the Orthodox receive only at an Orthodox chalice.
The strict canons are harder. Ancient rules forbid praying with heretics (Apostolic Canon 45; Laodicea 33), and some Orthodox read them as ruling out attendance at non-Orthodox worship altogether. Many bishops apply them more gently to family occasions, where your presence is an act of love and not a profession of faith; the canon stays the norm. Which reading your parish follows is a fair question for your priest, and the honest answer may differ between jurisdictions.
A good pattern: keep your own feast first, then go to your family. Go to the Nativity Liturgy, then to your parents' candlelight service. Sing what you can, stay quiet where you can't, and be the one who helps clean up afterward. Orthodox and Protestant, "What you do," is the closest page.
Sources: Apostolic Canon 45; Council of Laodicea, canon 33 (NPNF2 14).
What's the difference between an inquirer, a catechumen and a full member?
Three words get used all the time, and only the last two are formal steps.
An inquirer is anyone exploring Orthodoxy who hasn't made a formal commitment. It isn't a rank, and nobody keeps a list. You're welcome at everything—Liturgy, classes, coffee hour—whether you've been coming for a week or for ten years. Think of it as "I'm curious, and I'm showing up."
A catechumen (Greek katechoumenos, "one being instructed") is someone a priest has formally enrolled to prepare for baptism or chrismation. This is the first formal step. In the short rite, the Prayers at the Reception of Catechumens, the priest breathes on you, signs your forehead and breast with the cross, lays his hand on your head and prays that God would "inscribe [you] in thy Book of Life, and unite [you] to the flock of thine inheritance." Then comes a time of instruction. Where the petitions are said, the Church prays for you at every Liturgy, and the deacon's "Depart, all ye Catechumens, depart" is addressed to you. The petitions are said year-round in Slavic, Antiochian and OCA parishes and are usually omitted in Greek ones, and parishes differ on whether catechumens actually step out; The Litany of the Catechumens explains.
The faithful are the baptized and chrismated, the ones the deacon means by "us who are in the faith." If your baptism was one the Church accepts, you're received by chrismation; otherwise by baptism and chrismation. Which applies to you is the bishop's decision. How Converts Are Received lays it out. Once you're received, you're a full member and you receive Communion.
So an inquirer is exploring, a catechumen is enrolled and preparing, and the formal difference between them is the priest's prayers and blessing. The Path In: Inquirer, Catechumen, Reception follows the whole way, from the back pew to the chalice.
Sources: Hapgood, Service Book (1906), "The Prayers at the Reception of Catechumens," pp. 272–276; Divine Liturgy, p. 92 (Litany of the Catechumens). Field Guide pages The Path In, The Litany of the Catechumens and How Converts Are Received.
What should I wear to the Divine Liturgy?
Come comfortable. Orthodox Christians also approach the Liturgy with the seriousness of an important event, because they're coming to meet the King of all. Most people dress a notch above everyday, business casual or their Sunday best, and you'll see a little bit of everything. The most important thing is that you're there.
If you want something more specific, think modest and think about standing: you'll be on your feet for a while, so wear shoes you can stand in, and keep shorts and low-cut tops for another day. Customs on head coverings and jackets vary from parish to parish. The old advice is simple. About the year 200, Clement of Alexandria wrote that "woman and man are to go to church decently attired." What to Wear covers the details, including the one rule that really is enforced: a man takes his hat off.
Sources: Clement of Alexandria, The Instructor (Paedagogus) III.11, "Going to Church" (ANF 2). Field Guide page What to Wear.
Can someone who isn't Orthodox be a godparent?
No, the sponsor must be Orthodox. The sponsor answers for the child's Orthodox faith at the font and promises to help raise the child in it, so the person making those promises must belong to the Orthodox Church. The Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America states it plainly: a person who sponsors a candidate for Baptism or Chrismation "must be an Orthodox Christian in good standing and a supporting member of an Orthodox parish."
Sources: Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America, "Instructions for Weddings, Divorces, Baptisms, Funerals, and Memorials," Baptisms, https://www.goarch.org/-/instructions-for-weddings-divorces-baptisms-funerals-and-memorials.
