What you'll notice
Every Sunday the whole church says a line that took a council to write: "Begotten, not made; Being of one Essence with the Father" (The Creed in Plain Words). And every December, someone posts a meme of Saint Nicholas slapping a heretic across the face. Both come from the same city in what's now Turkey, in the year 325. One is the backbone of the Church's faith. The other showed up about a thousand years late.
What it's called
The First Ecumenical Council met at Nicea (also spelled Nicaea; today's İznik). The man at the center of the quarrel was Arius, a priest of Alexandria, and his teaching is Arianism: that the Son is a creature, the first and greatest of them, but a creature. The council's answer was one Greek word, homoousios (of one essence). A canon, in this story, is a rule, not a list of books (Myth: "The Council of Nicea picked the books of the Bible").
What's actually happening
Just out of the fire
These bishops were not far from the persecutions. In the East, Licinius had been persecuting Christians until Constantine defeated him, and the council's own canons speak of those who fell "during the tyranny of Licinius."1 Some bishops carried the proof. Paul of Neocaesarea had lost the use of both hands to a red-hot iron under Licinius. Paphnutius of Upper Thebes had been sent to the mines in the persecution before that, with his right eye put out and his left leg crippled, and Socrates reports that the emperor kissed the place where the eye had been.2 These were not men who treated doctrine as a hobby.
Arius and Alexander
In Alexandria, Bishop Alexander was teaching on the unity of the Trinity when his priest Arius objected. Socrates gives Arius's logic: "If the Father begot the Son, he that was begotten had a beginning of existence: and from this it is evident, that there was a time when the Son was not."3 That sounds tidy until you ask what it does to the Son. Alexander excommunicated Arius, the quarrel spilled into the streets, and Constantine, who wanted one peaceful Church, sent Bishop Hosius of Cordoba to settle it. It didn't work—so the emperor called a council.4
Who was in the room
Bishops came from Syria and Egypt, Asia and Pontus, Thrace and Greece, with a Persian, a Scythian and one famous bishop from Spain. Rome's bishop was too old to travel and sent two priests.5 Eusebius names no chairman, only "those who presided." Hosius is the likeliest: his name stands first on the surviving signature lists, and Athanasius asks of him, "When was there a Council held, in which he did not take the lead, and by right counsel convince every one?"6 Constantine spoke in Latin, through an interpreter, and begged them for peace.7 Athanasius, then Alexander's deacon, argued against the Arians—he was not a bishop and had no vote.8
The Church keeps the number 318 Fathers, and so does this Guide.9 Early accounts give lower figures, about 250 to 300, and not everyone signed: the signature lists, pieced together from Latin, Greek, Coptic and Syriac copies, carry about 220 names.10
One word
Scripture's own phrases weren't enough, because the Arian party could read each one its own way.11 So the council wrote a creed that said the Son is "of the substance of the Father," "begotten, not made," homoousios with the Father, and anathematized anyone who said "there was a time when the Son of God was not."12 Eusebius of Caesarea, who was there, says the emperor himself urged adding that single word and explained that it said nothing crude about God being divided.13 It's easy to picture Athanasius handing the council its vocabulary. Nothing in the sources says he did—his part was the decades spent defending it. Five bishops balked at first, and two Libyan bishops, Theonas and Secundus, held out to the end and shared Arius's sentence.14
How the 325 creed grew into the one in your hands is on The Creed and The Creed in Plain Words.
Twenty rules
The council also passed twenty canons on church order.15 A bishop is chosen by the bishops of his province, with at least three present, and the metropolitan ratifies (canon 4). Clergy are not to move from city to city (canons 15–16), nor lend at interest (canon 17). Deacons are not to give communion to priests or sit among them (canon 18). The last canon says to pray standing on Sundays and in the days of Pentecost (canon 20), which is why you stand (Standing, Sitting, Pews, and Kneeling).
Two things the canons don't say. None of the twenty deals with clergy marrying twice; that rule is in the older Apostolic Canons, which bar a man "twice married after baptism" from ordination. The one Nicene canon that mentions second marriages, canon 8, is about laypeople: returning Cathari had to agree to "communicate with persons who have been twice married."16 And canon 14 isn't about clergy at all: it is about catechumens who had lapsed, who spend three years as hearers and then pray with the catechumens.17
Socrates and Sozomen both report that Paphnutius, an Egyptian confessor-bishop, spoke against a proposed law that would have forbidden clergy who had married before ordination to live with their wives as husband and wife, and that the council left the matter to each man's own judgment, though some historians doubt the story.18
The council also settled the date of Pascha, though not the way the internet tells it. By 325 nearly every church kept Pascha on a Sunday. The holdouts were churches in Syria and Mesopotamia that took their Sunday from the synagogue's calendar, so that, as Constantine complained, the feast could come "twice in the same year." The council told them to keep one day with Rome, Alexandria and everyone else, reckoned by the Church rather than the synagogue.19 Its surviving letters stop there: no formula, no tables, and no rule that Pascha must follow Passover. The method came later, and so did the story that Nicea wrote it. Why Is Orthodox Easter on a Different Date? has the rest.
Legends and sources
Nicholas. The slap is a late legend. The earliest known text is a Latin book of saints by Petrus de Natalibus, a Venetian bishop of the late 1300s, and it says he struck "a certain Arian" on the jaw, not Arius.20 Whether Nicholas was at Nicea at all is an open question. He isn't on the shorter signature lists, usually taken as the oldest; he is on the longer ones, including the list of Theodore the Lector from about 515, which some scholars think was added to later. So his being there is neither proved nor ruled out.21 The story tells you how seriously later Christians took the fight. It tells you nothing about the hall.
Arius's death. He died in Constantinople about a decade later, in 336, on the eve of being received back into communion. Athanasius's account, in his letter to Serapion, is secondhand: "I was not at Constantinople when he died, but Macarius the Presbyter was, and I heard the account of it from him." He admits he hesitated to write, "fearing lest any one should suppose that I was exulting in the death of that man."22 Socrates tells it too, with more detail, and says the spot was still pointed out in Constantinople in his day.23
After Nicea
Nicea did not end the fight. Eusebius of Nicomedia and Theognis, exiled for refusing to sign Arius's deposition, recanted and were restored, and Athanasius, Alexander's successor, was sent into exile again and again.24 The matter was settled at Constantinople in 381, which confirmed the Nicene faith and expanded the Creed, and at Ephesus in 431, which forbade a rival creed.25 The Creed in Plain Words tells that part.
Why it matters
Nicea answered one question for all time: is the Son God, or only like God? The Fathers said he is God, of one essence with the Father, and the Church has confessed it ever since. It also shows how the Church handles its stories. The Church honors the 318 Fathers by that number. The old legends are loved too, and kept in their place—without being mistaken for the record. The faith doesn't depend on the slap.
Where it came from
We know Nicea from a handful of writers, mostly after the fact: Eusebius and Athanasius, who were there, and Socrates, Sozomen and Theodoret, who wrote later. No minutes of its debates survive. The council's own words are the creed, the twenty canons and its letter to the Church of Alexandria.26
What you do
If you're Orthodox: next Sunday, when you say "Begotten, not made," remember who wrote it. When the Nicholas meme goes around, enjoy it and say "that one's a legend." And if someone tells you what Nicea did or didn't decree, ask which canon.
If you're visiting: nothing is required of you. The whole church says the Creed together, and this is where it started.
Notes
-
Nicea I, canon 11 (NPNF2 14), on those who fell "during the tyranny of Licinius"; Socrates, Ecclesiastical History I.3–4 (NPNF2 2), on Licinius's persecution. ↩
-
Theodoret, Ecclesiastical History I.6 (NPNF2 3), on Paul of Neocaesarea and Licinius; Sozomen, Ecclesiastical History I.10 (NPNF2 2), on Paphnutius in the mines under Maximinus; Socrates I.11 (NPNF2 2), on the emperor kissing the empty eye socket. ↩
-
Socrates I.5 (NPNF2 2). ↩
-
Socrates I.6–8; Sozomen I.16–17 (NPNF2 2); Eusebius, Life of Constantine III.6 (NPNF2 1). ↩
-
Eusebius, Life of Constantine III.7 (NPNF2 1); Sozomen I.17 (NPNF2 2), who names the two priests. ↩
-
Eusebius, Life of Constantine III.11, III.13 (NPNF2 1); Athanasius, Defence of His Flight 5 and History of the Arians 42 (NPNF2 4); the signature lists in Gelzer, Hilgenfeld and Cuntz, Patrum Nicaenorum nomina (Leipzig, 1898). ↩
-
Eusebius, Life of Constantine III.10–13 (NPNF2 1). ↩
-
Socrates I.8 (NPNF2 2). ↩
-
Athanasius, To the Bishops of Africa 2 (NPNF2 4); Socrates I.8 (NPNF2 2); Theodoret, Ecclesiastical History I.6 (NPNF2 3). ↩
-
Eusebius, Life of Constantine III.8 (NPNF2 1), "exceeded two hundred and fifty"; Eustathius of Antioch, quoted in Theodoret I.7 (NPNF2 3), "about two hundred and seventy"; Athanasius, History of the Arians 66 (NPNF2 4), "three hundred of them, more or less." On the lists: Gelzer, Hilgenfeld and Cuntz (1898), 220 names; C. H. Turner, Ecclesiae Occidentalis Monumenta Iuris Antiquissima I (1899–1904), 218. ↩
-
Athanasius, To the Bishops of Africa 5 (NPNF2 4), also quoted in Theodoret I.7 (NPNF2 3). ↩
-
The Creed of Nicea I and its anathemas (NPNF2 14). ↩
-
Eusebius of Caesarea's letter to his church, in Socrates I.8 (NPNF2 2) and Theodoret I.11 (NPNF2 3). ↩
-
Socrates I.8 (NPNF2 2), on the five; the Synodal Letter of Nicea I (NPNF2 14), on Theonas and Secundus, who "received the same sentence." ↩
-
Nicea I, canons 4, 15, 16, 17, 18 and 20 (NPNF2 14). ↩
-
Apostolic Canons, canon 17, and Nicea I, canon 8 (NPNF2 14). ↩
-
Nicea I, canon 14 (NPNF2 14). ↩
-
Socrates, Ecclesiastical History I.11, and Sozomen, Ecclesiastical History I.23 (NPNF2 2). On the doubts: Hefele, History of the Councils I, in NPNF2 14 ("Proposed Action on Clerical Celibacy"), who reports that Baronius and Valesius judged the account apocryphal and finds Valesius's arguments from silence insufficient. ↩
-
Eusebius, Life of Constantine III.14 and III.18–19, Constantine's letter to the churches (NPNF2 1); the Synodal Letter of Nicea I (NPNF2 14); Athanasius, De Synodis 5 and To the Bishops of Africa 2 (NPNF2 4); Archbishop Peter (L'Huillier), The Church of the Ancient Councils (SVS Press, 1996), pp. 19–26. ↩
-
Petrus de Natalibus, Catalogus sanctorum (late fourteenth century; Lyon, 1508, fol. VII), in Gustav Anrich, Hagios Nikolaos I (Leipzig, 1913), p. 459. ↩
-
Gelzer, Hilgenfeld and Cuntz, Patrum Nicaenorum nomina (1898); Theodore the Lector, Tripartite History (about 515); Anrich, Hagios Nikolaos (1913–17). ↩
-
Athanasius, Letter 54, to Serapion, §§1–2 (NPNF2 4). ↩
-
Socrates I.37–38 (NPNF2 2). ↩
-
Socrates I.14, I.15 and I.35 (NPNF2 2); Athanasius, Letter 54, §4 (NPNF2 4), on Constantius. ↩
-
Constantinople I, canon 1 (381), and Ephesus, canon 7 (NPNF2 14). ↩
-
The creed, canons and Synodal Letter of Nicea I (NPNF2 14). On the missing minutes: The Cambridge Companion to the Council of Nicaea (2021), ch. 5 ("No Acts survive"). ↩
